Jump to Recipe

Are you ready to indulge in a delightful frozen treat that will tickle your taste buds and refresh your senses? Look no further than this mouthwatering Lemon Gelato served in natural lemon shells! This simple and satisfying recipe is not only a feast for the palate but also an eye-catching dessert that is sure to impress your guests.

This only has 4 ingredients, making it simple to make. Waiting for the ingredients to freeze is just the hardest part! Enjoy within a few days to maintain the best texture and flavor of the gelato.

1. Creating the Lemon Shells:

• To start, slice off the very bottom of 2 of the lemons, allowing them to stand upright without rolling over. Keep the sliced pieces aside.
• Carefully cut off the tops of the lemons and set them aside as well.
• Gently scoop out the pulp and seeds from the lemons using a spoon or citrus spoon, taking care not to pierce the lemon skin. Save the lemon juice and the thin pulp in a small dish while discarding the seeds and hard lemon skin/pulp.
• Place the hollowed-out lemon shells upright and insert the thin bottom pieces inside each lemon to seal any holes at the bottom. Then, put the tops of the lemons back on and place them in the freezer to harden. If you wish to keep them separate, put each lemon in a cup and cover with plastic wrap.

2. Preparing the Gelato Mixture:

• Zest the third lemon and add it to the reserved lemon juice/pulp in a small dish. Cover it with saran wrap and place it in the freezer until frozen.
• Once frozen, transfer the lemon zest and juice/pulp to a blender or food processor. Add the ice cubes and blend the mixture until smooth. Set it aside for later.

3. Whipping up the Creamy Gelato:

• In a large mixing bowl, combine the heavy whipping cream and powdered sugar. Use a whisk or an electric mixer to blend them until you achieve a smooth whipped cream texture.
• Now, fold the blended lemon mixture into the whipped cream bowl gently. The combination of zesty lemon and rich cream will tantalize your taste buds.

4. Filling the Lemon Shells:

• Retrieve the frozen lemon shells from the freezer and remove the tops. Carefully pour the prepared gelato mixture into each shell, filling them to the top. Place the tops back on the lemons and set them on a tray or plate. Then, return them to the freezer.
• Allow the gelato inside the lemons to freeze for at least 3 hours or until it reaches a firm and scoopable consistency.
• Any remaining lemon gelato can be poured into a freezer-safe container and kept frozen for later enjoyment.

Savor the Exquisite Lemon Gelato:

Once the gelato in the lemon shells has set, it’s time to relish this refreshing dessert. Take a spoon, scoop into the creamy lemon gelato, and experience the burst of citrusy flavors complemented by the creamy texture. This enchanting treat is perfect for hot summer days, gatherings with friends, or simply as a delightful ending to a delicious meal.